
In case I haven’t ever mentioned this, I am an esteemed alumnus of the Robert E. Cook Honors College of Indiana University of Pennsylvania (RECHC for short). For each unit of honors core we had to use the knowledge gained from our class to answer specific core questions. For instance, for my first unit the core question was: What is good, what is bad, therefore, what do I do? And joy of joys I got to take philosophy for that unit. My proffessor, Dr. B, was an intimidating but totally cool woman who started off the class by asking us why incest was wrong and then, when we gave reasons, she disproved all of them. And when we were all shaken and scared and convinced that incest was, in fact, totally ok, she informed us that it was wrong because it was a socially prescribed paradigm. Hello, world of relativity. Ugh.
Anyway, over the past couple weeks I have given some history of circumcision as well as my own personal experience with circumcision as an adult. And now that I have that knowledge, what do I do?
Well, I have to say that it is my belief that circumcision, like most of the other rules listed in Leviticus, was most likely enforced for hygiene purposes. Perhaps it was even a way for the people back then who followed the Jewish (or Muslim) religion to distinguish themselves from their gentile counterparts. In this day and age, however, I see foreskin pretty much the same way as I see tonsils; it’s a part of the body that does serve a specific function and removing it as a preventative measure or simply because it’s routine, does not make sense to me. Nor do I feel that it’s neccesary to physically alter any of my children as a means of showing a covenant to a god that I don’t believe exists.
Besides, I personally have pierced ears (and at one point my eyebrow and tongue were pierced too) and a tattoo, which, according to Judaism is a desecration of my body. Somehow I have a hard time seeing circumcision as being much different. In other words, if I have sons and they grow up and decide that, yes, they want to make their covenant with a particular god and that god demands foreskin, they are more than welcome to get a circumcision when they are old enough to decide for themselves. I won’t do that for them.
I’ve already discussed the matter with my parents (and even a lady from work…older Jewish women just looove to get all up in other people’s business, no matter how personal) and they understand our decision (this is CB’s decision too, by the way, not just mine). I figure the only people at this point who would be shocked to see foreskin on my babies would be my grandparents but I doubt they’ll ever have to change a diaper by the time we have kids, so no worries there.
So, I guess that nearly wraps us up. I’m trying to get a guest to post next Friday to give another perspective on circumcision before I bring Fridays For Skin to a close. Oh, and before I forget, as always, the contents herein are my opinion and my opinion only. I don’t think ill of parents who opt to circumcise their sons, it just simply isn’t what I plan to do.
Recent Comments